Why your fatigued but your thyroid labs show up as normal?

Joel Radley Functional Nutrition

Joel Radley

Thyroid problems are tricky—treatment only works if the diagnosis is right. Misdiagnosis? You’re stuck with the wrong fix, or worse, more harm. I see it every week.

Most people with hypothyroidism get a one-size-fits-all prescription for hormones, no digging for the real cause. If your lab tests look normal, despite feeling awful, you’ll probably get dismissed—or handed antidepressants.

But thyroid function is complex. Standard tests miss many issues. Below are five thyroid dysfunctions that don’t show up on regular labs, leaving you stuck in limbo.

1. T4 to T3 Conversion Failure

The body needs to convert inactive T4 to active T3. Stress and inflammation slow this down. Most lab tests won’t even check your T3. You’ll be told you’re fine—while your cells scream otherwise.

When your body’s caught in the throes of inflammation—whether from injury, an autoimmune issue, or some internal mess—things start to go sideways. Type 1 deiodinase, or D1, the enzyme that normally helps convert T4 into the more active T3 hormone, decides to slow down. So, instead of that smooth transition happening in the liver and kidneys, it stalls. The result? You’ve got more T4 floating around in your bloodstream than T3, and that imbalance? It’s like cooking with the wrong ingredients—something’s definitely off and can lead to a host of disorders(1).

2. Hypothyroidism from Low TBG

Low TBG sounds like a good thing, right? Wrong. It leads to resistance, where your cells just won’t use the hormones floating around. It’s common in women with PCOS or insulin resistance.

joel radley nutrition fatigue thyroid labs not showing markers low energy

3. Hypothyroidism from Pituitary Dysfunction

Stress from life, blood sugar swings, pregnancy, or insulin resistance floods your system with cortisol, wearing out the pituitary gland. It stops sending the thyroid proper signals. Tests show “normal,” but you’re still struggling.

4. Thyroid Resistance

TBG binds thyroid hormones in the blood, keeping them inactive. Too much TBG means your cells are starving for hormones, though lab results say everything’s fine.

5. Hypothyroidism from High TBG

TBG binds thyroid hormones in the blood, keeping them inactive. Too much TBG means your cells are starving for hormones, though lab results say everything’s fine.

6. Thyroid Antibodies

Thyroid antibodies tell another story, as up to 90% of hypothyroidism is autoimmune (hashimoto’s_, often missed (2).

I believe it’s a sign the body is trying to heal its thyroid glands, but its an alarm bell non the less, crying for intervention. Note: It cant just be based on antibodies as helpful of a marker as they may be, Elevated TSH, and low T3 or T4 is indicative.


Understanding Standard vs Functional Lab Ranges

Whats more well aside from the above 6 areas that most tests miss out on, here’s the kicker: Most GPs only test for TSH and maybe free T4. That’s it. But this barely scratches the surface.

Most labs use standard ranges based on the average population—many of whom are sick. These broad ranges miss a lot. Functional ranges, on the other hand, reflect the levels of healthy individuals, spotting thyroid problems before they spiral. Yet as mentioned above even with these more optimal ranges a lack of experience or the right research/knowledge/understanding of the thyroid can render such tests pointless or harmful.

Functional testing goes deeper, identifying patterns that help target treatment and manage your thyroid health. These patterns don’t just slip through the cracks—they also don’t respond to standard treatments. Piling on more T4 won’t fix a conversion issue or thyroid resistance. The only way out? A correct diagnosis. Once that’s dialed in, treatment works wonders

Warmly

Joel


Sick & Tired of Being Sick & Tired? Consider my 1:1 support options.

Sick & tired of being sick & tired? ⁣
Had enough of guessing?⁣
‘DIY’ ing your health?⁣
Random supplements?⁣
The practitioner or diet carousel? ⁣
Feel unwell but labs show your fine? ⁣
Stuck on that same page of your book before crashing to sleep?
Coffee dependency keeping you moving?

If you want to learn how to:⁣

-Energise⁣
-Balance hormones⁣
-Heal fatigue, brain fog, bloating & more⁣
-Look & feel amazing to show up for what matters to you⁣
-Be your own healer⁣

Book a free call now on my calendar booker.

FAQ: Are You Accepting New Clients?

Yes, I am! My schedule is usually booked out 2-4 weeks in advance, depending on the time of year, but I do onboard new clients once a month. Rescheduling also happens, so there’s often a spot that opens up. You can Book on Calendly, or email me directly with any questions.

Let’s get your energy flowing again, to have the energy you want when you want, and to show up for matters to you in your life, now!

“My Four-Pillar Protocol is designed to heal you on four planes, the physical is the bulk of our work together (Nutrition + Exercise + Grounding + Therapeutics), yet we will also touch on the emotional (Self-enquiry, Experiential-therapy, Connection to others + Objectivity to emotions), the Mental (Perspective + Meditation + Goals + Objectivity to thought), & the Spiritual ( Connection to higher self & all + Gratitude + Breath-work to reconnect.)”

Sources

1 -https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9197626/

2-https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0950351X88800557#:~:text=Hypothyroidism%20can%20be%20induced%20by,mostly%20due%20to%20Hashimoto’s%20disease.

Share this Article

Picture of About Joel Radley

About Joel Radley

Joel Radley dipNT, BSc (Hons), mBANT, mCNHC, functional nutritionist specialising in root-cause natural healthcare, ancestral eating & lifestyle. Developer of the four-pillar protocol to help clients holistically, covering nutrition, energetics, emotions and mindfulness. I help concerns of the thyroid, adrenal, fatigue, hormones, gut health, eating disorders & chronic pain.

For over a decade supporting individuals like you and me, high performers, creatives, public figures and entrepreneurs, unlock their dormant healing power and optimize their health potential. I hope you will enjoy the videos, articles & recipes I share on my website, blog & social media. If you have a deeper concern that requires the help of an expert practitioner, do not hesitate and join the waiting list by booking a free call on the calendar. Warmly, Joel

Picture of About Joel Radley

About Joel Radley

Joel Radley dipNT, BBC (Hons), mBANT, mCNHC, nutritional therapist and naturopath specialising in root-cause natural healthcare, ancestral eating & lifestyle.

Developer of the four-pillar protocol to help clients holistically, covering nutrition, energetics, emotions and mindfulness. I help concerns of the thyroid, adrenal, fatigue, hormones, gut health, eating disorders & chronic pain.

For over a decade supporting individuals like you and me, high performers, creatives, public figures and entrepreneurs, unlock their dormant healing power and optimize their health potential.

I hope you will enjoy the free videos, articles & recipes I share on my website, blog and social media. If you have a deeper concern that requires the help of an expert practitioner, do not hesitate and join the waiting list by booking a free call on the calendar. Warmly, Joel